nixos-servers/docs/plans/nix-cache-reprovision.md

# Nix Cache Host Reprovision

## Overview

Reprovision `nix-cache01` using the OpenTofu workflow, and improve the build/cache system with:
1. NATS-based remote build triggering (replacing the current bash script)
2. Safer flake update workflow that validates builds before pushing to master

## Status

**Phase 1: New Build Host** - COMPLETE
**Phase 2: NATS Build Triggering** - COMPLETE
**Phase 3: Safe Flake Update Workflow** - NOT STARTED
**Phase 4: Complete Migration** - COMPLETE

## Completed Work

### New Build Host (nix-cache02)

Instead of reprovisioning nix-cache01 in-place, we created a new host `nix-cache02` at 10.69.13.25:

- **Specs**: 8 CPU cores, 16GB RAM (temporarily, will increase to 24GB after nix-cache01 decommissioned), 200GB disk
- **Provisioned via OpenTofu** with automatic Vault credential bootstrapping
- **Builder service** configured with two repos:
  - `nixos-servers` → `git+https://git.t-juice.club/torjus/nixos-servers.git`
  - `nixos` (gunter) → `git+https://git.t-juice.club/torjus/nixos.git`

### NATS-Based Build Triggering

The `homelab-deploy` tool was extended with a builder mode:

**NATS Subjects:**
- `build.<repo>.<target>` - e.g., `build.nixos-servers.all` or `build.nixos-servers.ns1`

**NATS Permissions (in DEPLOY account):**
| User | Publish | Subscribe |
|------|---------|-----------|
| Builder | `build.responses.>` | `build.>` |
| Test deployer | `deploy.test.>`, `deploy.discover`, `build.>` | `deploy.responses.>`, `deploy.discover`, `build.responses.>` |
| Admin deployer | `deploy.>`, `build.>` | `deploy.>`, `build.responses.>` |

**Vault Secrets:**
- `shared/homelab-deploy/builder-nkey` - NKey seed for builder authentication

**NixOS Configuration:**
- `hosts/nix-cache02/builder.nix` - Builder service configuration
- `services/nats/default.nix` - Updated with builder NATS user

**MCP Integration:**
- `.mcp.json` updated with `--enable-builds` flag
- Build tool available via MCP for Claude Code

**Tested:**
- Single host build: `build nixos-servers testvm01` (~30s)
- All hosts build: `build nixos-servers all` (16 hosts in ~226s)

### Harmonia Binary Cache

- Parameterized `services/nix-cache/harmonia.nix` to use hostname-based Vault paths
- Parameterized `services/nix-cache/proxy.nix` for hostname-based domain
- New signing key: `nix-cache02.home.2rjus.net-1`
- Vault secret: `hosts/nix-cache02/cache-secret`
- Removed unused Gitea Actions runner from nix-cache01

## Current State

### nix-cache02 (Active)
- Running at 10.69.13.25
- Serving `https://nix-cache.home.2rjus.net` (canonical URL)
- Builder service active, responding to NATS build requests
- Metrics exposed on port 9973 (`homelab-deploy-builder` job)
- Harmonia binary cache server running
- Signing key: `nix-cache02.home.2rjus.net-1`
- Prod tier with `build-host` role

### nix-cache01 (Decommissioned)
- VM deleted from Proxmox
- Host configuration removed from repo
- Vault AppRole and secrets removed
- Old signing key removed from trusted-public-keys

## Remaining Work

### Phase 3: Safe Flake Update Workflow

1. Create `.github/workflows/flake-update-safe.yaml`
2. Disable or remove old `flake-update.yaml`
3. Test manually with `workflow_dispatch`
4. Monitor first automated run

### Phase 4: Complete Migration ✅

1. ~~**Add Harmonia to nix-cache02**~~ ✅ Done - new signing key, parameterized service
2. ~~**Add trusted public key to all hosts**~~ ✅ Done - `system/nix.nix` updated
3. ~~**Test cache from other hosts**~~ ✅ Done - verified from testvm01
4. ~~**Update proxy and DNS**~~ ✅ Done - `nix-cache.home.2rjus.net` CNAME now points to nix-cache02
5. ~~**Deploy to all hosts**~~ ✅ Done - all hosts have new trusted key
6. ~~**Decommission nix-cache01**~~ ✅ Done - 2026-02-10:
   - Removed `hosts/nix-cache01/` directory
   - Removed `services/nix-cache/build-flakes.{nix,sh}`
   - Removed Vault AppRole and secrets
   - Removed old signing key from `system/nix.nix`
   - Removed from `flake.nix`
   - Deleted VM from Proxmox

### Phase 5: Scheduled Builds (Optional)

Add a systemd timer on nix-cache02 to trigger periodic builds via NATS:

```nix
systemd.services.scheduled-build = {
  script = ''
    homelab-deploy build nixos-servers --all
    homelab-deploy build nixos --all
  '';
};
systemd.timers.scheduled-build = {
  wantedBy = [ "timers.target" ];
  timerConfig.OnCalendar = "*-*-* *:30:00";
};
```

Or trigger builds from CI after merges to master.

## Resolved Questions

- **Parallel vs sequential builds?** Sequential - hosts share packages, subsequent builds are fast after first
- **What about gunter?** Configured as `nixos` repo in builder settings
- **Disk size?** 200GB for new host
- **Build host specs?** 8 cores, 16-24GB RAM matches current nix-cache01

### Phase 6: Observability

1. **Alerting rules** for build failures:
   ```promql
   # Alert if any build fails
   increase(homelab_deploy_build_host_total{status="failure"}[1h]) > 0

   # Alert if no successful builds in 24h (scheduled builds stopped)
   time() - homelab_deploy_build_last_success_timestamp > 86400
   ```

2. **Grafana dashboard** for build metrics:
   - Build success/failure rate over time
   - Average build duration per host (histogram)
   - Build frequency (builds per hour/day)
   - Last successful build timestamp per repo

Available metrics:
- `homelab_deploy_builds_total{repo, status}` - total builds by repo and status
- `homelab_deploy_build_host_total{repo, host, status}` - per-host build counts
- `homelab_deploy_build_duration_seconds_{bucket,sum,count}` - build duration histogram
- `homelab_deploy_build_last_timestamp{repo}` - last build attempt
- `homelab_deploy_build_last_success_timestamp{repo}` - last successful build

## Open Questions

- [x] ~~When to cut over DNS from nix-cache01 to nix-cache02?~~ Done - 2026-02-10
- [ ] Implement safe flake update workflow before or after full migration?